top of page

Why Does My Shoulder Pop When I Bench Press?

Nashville Physical Therapy
23 hours ago
6 min read
bench press

First rep: pop. You pause, rotate the shoulder, decide it's fine. Second set: pop, pop. By the fourth set you've mentally cataloged every shoulder sound and convinced yourself it's either nothing or your labrum is shredded and you need surgery by Friday.


Neither extreme is likely. Shoulder popping during bench press is one of the more common gym-floor complaints, and the range of what's actually causing it runs from genuinely harmless gas-bubble cavitation all the way to a labral tear — with several much-more-likely, much-more-treatable possibilities in between.


Shoulder popping during bench press most commonly stems from one of four mechanisms: harmless gas-bubble cavitation (the same mechanism as cracking knuckles), subacromial impingement where the rotator cuff tendon contacts the underside of the acromion during pressing, a biceps tendon snapping in or out of its groove as the shoulder moves through the pressing arc, or a labral tear where the torn cartilage catches during specific positions. The single most useful clinical distinction is whether the popping is accompanied by pain, weakness, catching, or instability — painless popping is overwhelmingly benign, while popping paired with any of those features warrants assessment.


Here's how to figure out which category yours falls into and when to actually worry.


Why Does My Shoulder Pop When I Bench Press?:


The Painless Pop: Almost Certainly Nothing


If your shoulder pops during bench press without any accompanying pain, without a sense of catching or the joint "getting stuck," without weakness, and without a feeling of instability — it's very likely harmless. Gas-bubble cavitation in the shoulder joint is common, normal, and produces the same kind of popping sound as cracking your knuckles.


Tendon snapping over bone is another frequent, painless source. The biceps tendon and the muscles around the shoulder blade shift position slightly during the pressing arc, and certain positions — particularly the bottom of the bench press where the shoulder is in maximal horizontal abduction and external rotation — can create a palpable snap as a tendon slides over a bony prominence.


This is the majority of gym-floor shoulder pops. The benchmark for concern isn't the sound itself — it's what accompanies it.


Impingement: When It Pops and Aches


Subacromial impingement is probably the most common cause of popping that actually comes with discomfort during bench press. The rotator cuff tendons — particularly the supraspinatus — pass through a narrow space between the top of the humerus and the underside of the acromion (the bony shelf of the shoulder blade). During pressing movements, if this space is compressed further by poor shoulder blade positioning, excessive flaring of the elbows, or rotator cuff weakness, the tendon gets pinched.


This often produces a clicking or popping sensation with an accompanying ache — typically felt in the front or top of the shoulder, worse during the middle portion of the pressing range where the tendon is most compressed.


Form is a major driver here. Bench pressing with the elbows flared out at 90 degrees (straight out to the side) significantly increases impingement compared to tucking the elbows to roughly 45-75 degrees. Many lifters discover that a simple elbow-angle adjustment meaningfully changes the popping pattern — which is itself diagnostic, since impingement responds to mechanical changes while a labral tear or cavitation wouldn't.


Biceps Tendon: The Snapping That Tracks With Position


The long head of the biceps tendon sits in a groove at the front of the shoulder, and during certain movements it can partially slide out of and back into that groove — producing a palpable, sometimes audible snap. In bench press specifically, this tends to happen at the bottom of the movement where the shoulder is in its most extended, externally rotated position.


Biceps tendon snapping is usually felt at the very front of the shoulder and often has a consistent, reproducible quality — it happens at the same point in the movement almost every time, rather than randomly. Mild irritation of the tendon from repeated snapping can develop over time, producing a dull ache that concentrates at the front of the shoulder during or after pressing.


Labral Tear: The One Worth Ruling Out


This is the scenario most people fear, and while it's less common than impingement or tendon snapping, it does happen — particularly in lifters who've been pressing heavy for years.


A labral tear produces popping or catching with a distinctly different quality than the other causes. People often describe it as feeling like something "catches" or "gets stuck" briefly inside the joint, rather than a clean pop-and-done sensation. It's frequently accompanied by a deep ache inside the shoulder (not surface-level), a sense of instability during the lift, and sometimes pain that radiates down the arm.


The bottom of the bench press — where the shoulder is maximally loaded in a vulnerable position — is exactly where a labral tear is most likely to produce symptoms, since that's the position where the torn cartilage is most likely to catch between the ball and socket.

If popping is consistently accompanied by deep catching, instability, or a sense that the shoulder isn't holding its position properly during pressing, assessment becomes important rather than optional.


What Assessment Involves


Evaluation starts with reproducing the popping — not just in the clinic, but understanding exactly where in the pressing arc it occurs and what quality it has. Specific shoulder tests help differentiate impingement from labral involvement from biceps tendon issues. Rotator cuff strength testing identifies weakness that may be contributing to impingement. Scapular positioning assessment reveals whether the shoulder blade is moving properly during pressing (poor scapular control is one of the most common and most correctable contributors to impingement-related popping).


What Treatment Typically Involves


For impingement, treatment centers on rotator cuff strengthening, scapular stabilization training, and bench press form modification — particularly elbow angle, grip width, and shoulder blade positioning on the bench. Proper scapular retraction during pressing reduces the impingement space significantly.


For biceps tendon snapping, treatment addresses the factors keeping the tendon irritated — often shoulder internal rotation tightness, anterior shoulder overload from excessive pressing volume, and rotator cuff balance.


For suspected labral involvement, conservative treatment focused on shoulder stability and strength is the appropriate starting point, with more thorough evaluation (including imaging) reserved for cases that don't respond or where the clinical picture strongly suggests significant structural damage.


When It's Worth Getting This Looked At


Worth scheduling an evaluation if: shoulder popping during bench press is consistently accompanied by pain, you feel catching or a sense of the shoulder "getting stuck" during the lift, you've noticed weakness or instability during pressing, the popping has changed — either new onset or getting progressively worse, or you want to continue pressing heavy and want to make sure the shoulder is structurally handling it well.


Common Questions About Shoulder Popping During Bench Press


If it doesn't hurt, should I worry about it?

Painless popping without catching, weakness, or instability is overwhelmingly benign. Sound alone, in the absence of associated symptoms, does not indicate damage.


Will changing my grip width help?

It can — a wider grip increases shoulder abduction and impingement risk, while a narrower grip reduces it. Experimenting with grip width is a reasonable first step for impingement-related popping.


Should I stop bench pressing?

Usually not — modifying form, load, and volume is typically more productive than stopping entirely. Complete avoidance doesn't address the underlying issue and leaves you deconditioned when you return.


Could this be arthritis?

In younger lifters, unlikely. In lifters over 50 or those with a long lifting history, acromioclavicular (AC) joint arthritis is a possibility, producing pain and crepitus localized to the top of the shoulder.


Is a labral tear always surgical?

No — many labral tears are managed successfully with conservative treatment. Surgery is generally reserved for significant tears that don't respond to a genuine course of rehabilitation.


Does the popping mean I'm damaging something with every rep?

Painless popping is not damaging the joint. Popping with pain may indicate that the pressing position is repeatedly irritating a structure, which is worth addressing to prevent progression.


Will rotator cuff exercises alone fix this?

Rotator cuff strengthening helps, but scapular stabilization is equally important and often overlooked. The shoulder blade's position during pressing directly influences how much space the rotator cuff has to work within.


Is incline bench better or worse for shoulder popping than flat?

This varies by individual — incline changes the shoulder angle and loading pattern, which helps some people and worsens symptoms for others. Assessment determines which pressing variations work best for your specific shoulder.


Why Does My Shoulder Pop When I Bench Press?: Bottom Line


Shoulder popping during bench press ranges from completely harmless (gas bubbles, tendon snapping) through mildly annoying but fixable (impingement, biceps tendon irritation) to genuinely worth investigating (labral tears). The sound itself isn't the concern — what accompanies it is. Painless popping is almost always fine. Popping with pain, catching, weakness, or instability deserves a closer look, because the sooner impingement patterns and form issues are addressed, the less likely they are to progress into something that actually limits your training.


Shoulder popping that's bothering you during pressing?

Schedule a Physical Therapy Evaluation at Nashville Physical Therapy & Performance. You'll get completely 1:1 care with your therapist for the entire visit — no aides, no split attention. We'll figure out exactly what's causing the pop and whether it needs addressing or just monitoring. Available at East Nashville, West Nashville/The Nations, Brentwood, and Goodlettsville. Call 615-428-9213 or book online at nashvillept.com.


References

[^1]: CityPT. What's Causing Shoulder Pain from Bench Press? Clinical physical therapy reference. 2024.

[^2]: Larson Sports Ortho. 5 Simple Ways to Stop Shoulder Pain During Bench Press. Clinical orthopedic reference. 2020.

[^3]: NY Sports Medicine Institute. Shoulder Crunching and Popping: Causes and Treatment Options. Clinical orthopedic reference. 2026.

Comments


bottom of page